Best Mustard For Hot Dogs (Complete List)

Hot dogs are one of the world’s favorite meats, and you can eat hot dogs alone, in a bun, or as a whole meal. Mustard is one of the world’s favorite condiments, so pairing mustard and hot dogs are perfect.

With all the mustard varieties available, you may be wondering what the best mustard is for hot dogs. I did the research, and here is what I discovered!

Best Mustard For Hot Dogs

1. Yellow Mustard

Yellow mustard is classic and yellow mustard is the first mustard ever put on top of a hot dog.

Yellow mustard, or American mustard, is probably the most popular and most used hot dog mustard in the world.

No hot dog carts or diners will be complete without the option of putting yellow mustard on top of your hot dog.

Is yellow mustard the best for a hot dog? Well, that would depend on who you are asking.

Some people swear by yellow mustard while others think yellow mustard is overrated. Nevertheless, yellow mustard is and will always be a classic condiment for hot dogs.

2. Spicy Brown Mustard

People who have tried spicy brown mustard argue that spicy brown mustard is the best mustard to put on a hot dog.

Spicy brown mustard has heat and kick that contrasts with the meat-packed flavor of the hot dog and offers just enough flavor to not overpower the hot dog as well.

Additionally, spicy brown mustard is also known as deli mustard, thus spicy brown mustard is great with a lot of deli meats.

3. Whole Grain Mustard

Whole grain mustard is great for added texture because whole grain mustard adds crunch and a bite to hot dogs.

Aside from the classic mustard heat whole grain mustard gives, whole grain mustard also offers a creaminess and fullness to the hot dog because of whole grain mustard’s thick consistency.

While whole grain mustard may not be the first mustard variety you think of when you think of a hot dog, whole grain mustard does work.

4. Honey Mustard

Honey Mustard

If you like a sweeter contrast to the otherwise salty flavor of the hot dog, honey mustard is great as a hot dog topping.

People who love mustard but prefer a sweeter or milder one always turn to honey mustard.

Plus, honey mustard is great for dipping and great with most meats so a hot dog is no different.

5. Spicy German Mustard

German mustards are great with any kind of meat. Spicy German mustard is especially good because spicy German mustard cuts through the rich flavor of the meat without overpowering the hot dog.

Moreover, spicy German mustard’s heat also makes the hot dog more enjoyable to eat for those who love a kick of spiciness.

6. Ballpark Mustard

Ballpark mustard, or stadium mustard, is not your typical brown mustard because ballpark mustard is a mildly spicy brown mustard that is famous in stadiums all around the world as a hot dog topping.

Some people prefer ballpark mustard over the traditional yellow mustard or the famous brown deli mustard.

Additionally, ballpark mustard is very famous in Cleveland, and people there only use ballpark mustard for their hot dogs.

What Is The Best Yellow Mustard For Hot Dogs?

According to many surveys, many people love Heinz’s Yellow Mustard on their hot dogs.

People claim that Heinz’s formulation is the classic taste of yellow mustard and has the old-fashioned mustard flavor they love.

People who tried Heinz Yellow Mustard said that it is exactly how mustard should taste with a little acidity balanced by a hint of sweetness.

Additionally, Heinz Yellow Mustard also has the mustard tang that people love on their meat.

Plochman’s is a close contender, and Plochman’s is mostly because of the easy squeeze tube Plochman’s mustard comes in.

What Is The Best Brown Mustard For Hot Dogs?

People who love putting spicy brown mustard on their hot dogs say that Plochman’s Kosciusko line of spicy brown mustard is the best.

Plochman’s Kosciusko mustard has a creamy and zesty taste that adds flavor to the hot dog.

While Plochman’s Kosciusko mustard is not a very known line of brown mustard, people who have tried it swear by Plochman’s Kosciusko mustard.

Furthermore, Plochman’s Kosciusko mustard is slowly gaining traction and popularity as one of the tastiest mustard brands.

Take a look at our related articles to learn about honey mustard substitutes, ground mustard substitutes, and Dijon mustard substitutes.


Many people think that only the classic yellow mustard is a great pair for hot dogs, but you can in fact use any mustard you want, and you can mix different mustards or add more ingredients.

It does not matter if you prefer smooth mustard or a textured, grainy one since every kind of mustard will still give you the same classic mustard taste with varying levels of intensity and flavor.

Leave a Comment